Recommended for you
How to Stop Motor Carriers from Destroying Hours-of-Service (HOS) Logs
HOS Logs: Can Motor Carriers Delete or Destroy Them? Hours-of-Service (HOS) records can be critical evidence in a commercial truck accident. These records may evidence the length of time a driver was working, when he or she was driving, during which periods they were off-duty, and whether their accounted hours align with recorded, corroborated impact.
For that reason, keeping HOS records can serve a crucial purpose in truck accidents if the vehicle collides with someone suffering severe injuries or a wrongful death claim arises; disputes regarding driver fatigue may also arise. The bright side here is that federal regulations require motor carriers to keep certain records. Motor carriers are required to have RODS and supporting documents, as per FMCSA, for 6 months.
Under federal HOS rules, most drivers required to maintain RODS use an electronic logging device (ELD), with some exceptions. These records can present an important timeline of a driver's time cards and driving activity.
Truck Accident HOS (Hours of Service) Logs. These records are important, as they can be used to ascertain how many hours a driver had been on their shift before the accident and if any rest periods were taken as required by law. These documents help verify the history of driving hours and breaks taken by a driver.
This information can be particularly beneficial in accident investigations when there are suspicions of driver fatigue or excessive driving.
Motor carriers do not have the luxury of ignoring federal recordkeeping obligations simply because those records may be inconvenient or paint them in an unfavorable light. Motor carriers that do not use ELDs are required to provide a Record of Duty Status (RODS).
However, that is not to say every missing record shows some form of wrongdoing. There may be various reasons for an absence of a record, and the legal consequences surrounding said missing evidence are based upon both situation-specific factors and applicable law.
If you are concerned about missing big pieces of HOS records, preservation should be attended to as early in your investigation process per instance as possible. The truck accident victim can identify relevant documents and issue a preservation of evidence request through proper legal channels.
Other records showing driver activity. The specifics of the accident will determine whether you have actual records.
Spoliation or preservation letter you may have to send this in a serious truck accident investigation. Preservation letters tell the recipient that this information could become relevant to a potential claim and must be preserved. You can find these categories in a preservation request:
A preservation letter could be a critical component during an extensive truck accident investigation. It is intended to inform the recipient that certain information may be pertinent with respect to an impending claim. This is a letter requesting to preserve the evidence that we need. This can minimize the risk of vital info getting rid of or deleted.
Preservation requests can be used to establish different categories of evidence related to an accident. It may comprise documents, records, and reports from companies. Information about the vehicle and your record as a driver can also play a role. Identifying the evidence helps streamline the investigation.
Electronic records may be crucial evidence in truck accident cases as well. This may include GPS data, electronic logging information, and vehicle data. This could include emails and other forms of communication over the internet too. These records will come in handy when it is time to discover things later.
The one I discussed here is a preservation letter, which serves to preserve necessary evidence for an expected legal matter. This gives the recipient formal notice that they must preserve information concerning relevant facts. Preserving it properly keeps the evidence available throughout investigations. Because of this, an intention to preserve a letter may be a beneficial tool in major truck accident cases.
Just because a preservation letter has been sent does not necessarily mean that every record requested will be produced. The purpose is to give the other side notice that evidence may be significant and should not be destroyed.
Transmission records of the electronic mobile communication through the fleet-management system. Payroll records, settlement sheets, or similar documents showing payments made to the driver. These records have the potential to verify a timeline independent of the driver's HOS record.
One critical safeguard for any HOS evidence obtained through this provision is that the permitted correction will not eliminate the initial ELD record. If a driver is not able to access their records on their own, it becomes incumbent upon the motor carrier to furnish copies of requested documents within six months according to regulation.
The record edited is not equal to the original from which it came. The history of changes may come into consideration in a serious accident investigation.
You must keep records and documents in support of motor carriers as required by Federal HOS recordkeeping. Meanwhile, the carrier is also required to keep another copy of each ELD data in a separate device for 6 months. Records must be kept in a way that maintains the privacy of drivers. This six-month window turns prompt evidence preservation into an especially critical issue. Legal claims can run far longer than the federal HOS retention period.
Thus, it is likely not safe to assume that a truck accident claim can wait several months before preservation.
The FMCSA expressly identifies several of these classifications as supporting documentation for authenticating RODS. If they declare that the driver was off-duty, but fuel receipts and dispatch records reveal he is on a trip at this time, these reports may raise doubts about further inquiries into any event.
FMCSA mandates that RODS and accompanying paperwork be preserved for six months if they are governed. Data from the ELD can also be backed up and is required to be kept for a minimum of six months. If months have gone by since the accident, pertinent records may be close to the end of their federal retention period. This does not mean that the records are already gone or there is no other evidence.
Yet it demonstrates the need for prompt preservation if a possible legal claim is to be made.
A preservation request that is vague too; it should be specific enough so they may easily identify and preserve the relevant evidence. This must include an overview of the case or matter, dates, and what personnel or accounts are relevant to be retained in records. It may also specify relevant emails, messages, documents, files, tx logs, or other forms of digital proof.
This simplifies what the organization must preserve as evidence and from what time period.
| Evidence Category | Examples |
|---|---|
| HOS and ELD Records | Records of duty status, ELD data, ELD backup data, original ELD records, permitted edits and annotations, ELD-related records |
| Trip and Dispatch Records | Dispatch messages, trip assignments, bills of lading, delivery records, route information, schedules |
| Electronic Records | Fleet-management communications, GPS information, electronic messages, other relevant electronic records |
| Business Records | Payroll records, settlement sheets, fuel receipts, toll records |
The ELD rules that the FMCSA established to promote their mandate first included protections against driver harassment derived from data related to an electronic logging device or infra-technologies. According to the FMCSA, the ELD rule prohibits harassment of drivers using data obtained via an electronic logging device (ELD) or other connected technology and includes a complaint process for drivers who feel they have been subjected to harassment.
It is important for you, as your good and timely recording of the duty status directly reflects on HOS records. Allegations of the fact that a carrier pressured me to change records or HOS violations, once made by me, may prompt separate investigations.
Not all drivers are required to use an ELD 100% of the time. FMCSA identifies a limited number of exceptions to the ELD requirement.
You are exempt from using paper RODS in conjunction with a dynamic list that includes certain specific short-haul operations; drivers who have no more than 8 days in a 7-day cottage period during the preceding 30-day period; and operators under certain special note principles, such as drive-away-tow-away operation purposes and pre-2000 manufactured vehicles. An exempt driver is still subject to HOS recordkeeping requirements.
Thus, the first thing that an investigation needs to uncover is what recordkeeping system was in effect for a driver at the time of any accident.
There are multiple potential records collected and saved with different companies/systems. Certain records exist in electronic format, while some are only available for a limited period of time. The longer an investigation is delayed, the more likely it is that data gets overwritten, deleted, or otherwise rendered hard to recover in normal business processes. The response: This means that early identification and preservation of potentially relevant records can help protect critical evidence.
Many different records can be involved in a truck accident investigation. Some of these records are most likely housed at numerous companies and in multiple systems. A portion of the data belongs to the driver, and some belong to other trucking companies. So the first step is always your initial identification of records.
A lot of records for accident cases pass through electronic digital storage. They may be vehicle data, electronic logs, or digital communications. Limited electronic information in some systems is available only for certain specified durations. As such, early preservation can help safeguard evidence.
By postponing an investigation, there is a greater chance of relevant data being lost. A record can be automatically overwritten or deleted as part of normal business processes. Other data might become difficult to recover later. Hence, it is helpful to rapidly recognize related evidence.
Early identification and preservation of potentially relevant records can sometimes be crucial. This algorithm can minimize the probability of accidentally losing evidence. These pieces of preserved information may be useful for further investigations. Timeliness also serves to render the investigation more complete and systematic.
One key type of evidence from HOS logs is the driver duty status and activity before a truck accident. Covered motor carriers are required by federal rules to retain HOS logs and supporting documents for a record period of 6 months but must keep another backup, as is also needed with ELD records. If there is concern that HOS records (or other evidence) are going to go missing, then early preservation may be the key.
That can include ELD data, original records themselves, and other supporting documentation like dispatch info, GPS documents & payroll information, along with any relevant evidence. The rules regarding preservation of evidence and the potential repercussions for lost or destroyed evidence are case- and jurisdiction-dependent. So if you have been in a serious truck accident, then see an attorney about what preservation steps need to be taken.
The federal requirements state that RODS and supporting documents for non-exempt motor carriers must be kept for six months. Furthermore, another backup copy of ELD information has to be saved for a period of at least six months.
Circumstances should be investigated. Questions such as deletion, retention policies, backup, notice of potential claim, and related records will come into question. The legal implications are factual and depend on the law.
Where a legal claim may arise from serious accidents, preserving evidence can also be important. A qualified attorney can assess and recommend appropriate preservation measures for the instant case.